A Respectful Distance
I recently stumbled upon an old photograph I made in June 1999 while working as a staff photographer for The Associated Press. I had been assigned to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, to cover the funeral of two Amish sisters who had died in a tragic accident.
Photographing the Amish community requires a great deal of sensitivity and respect. Many Amish prefer not to have their photographs taken, particularly during deeply personal moments such as a funeral. Knowing I wouldn't be making close-up photographs, I packed an extra-long lens, a manual-focus 500mm Nikkor that I had also used to cover Phillies games.
I positioned myself along a rural road in Gap, Pennsylvania, as horse-drawn buggies passed by. I respectfully avoided making close-up photographs of grieving family members and initially experimented with more abstract compositions that wouldn't reveal faces. Nothing seemed to work.
Eventually, I moved to a nearby open field. Suddenly, a procession of horse-drawn buggies began moving along the road, creating an opportunity to photograph the gathering from a distance. It was the image I had been looking for: a long procession of mourners that conveyed the scale and solemnity of the occasion without intruding on anyone's grief.
There was one unavoidable distraction: a car that happened to enter the frame in the background. That's photojournalism. You work with what unfolds in front of you.
It was a sad assignment, but I felt I had found a way to tell the story while respecting the privacy and traditions of the Amish community. Sometimes, the most meaningful photographs are made not by getting closer, but by knowing when to keep your distance.